Comments on: Will Supplementing or Switching To Formula Help Your Breastfeeding Baby Sleep? https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/ Get rid of frustrating baby sleep problems and heartbreaking tears with our baby sleep guides and sleep consultations that let you get the rest you need! Thu, 30 Dec 2021 03:38:42 +0000 hourly 1 By: Debbye @ The Baby Sleep Site https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-4/#comment-139377 Fri, 26 Jul 2019 23:37:50 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-139377 In reply to Mary.

Hi @Mary –
Thank you for writing. I am truly sorry that you have gotten the wrong idea about The Baby Sleep Site and our philosophies. The whole premise behind the site is not to scare or shame any families, but to let you know that all families and all babies are different, that there is no cookie cutter answer, and that no matter the family’s needs, and no matter the family’s choices for feeding or sleep, we are here to help!
We are very happy to hear that moving to formula helped your family sleep better, but in our 10+ years of experience, this is not always the case. We want to share our experience with sleep and how it can relate to feedings. We strive to empower all parents, and to encourage them to believe in themselves and know that there is nothing wrong with their baby, or with the parents, if he or she doesn’t follow what a book says he should do. We do truly want to help, and we again apologize that we did not get this point across well in the article that you read. Good luck to you in your continued journey to great sleep!

]]>
By: Mary https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-4/#comment-139286 Thu, 25 Jul 2019 17:58:53 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-139286 I am a mother of a four month old that still wakes up every two hours a night. On top of that I am about to go back to work. We switched to formula and our baby slept five hours. I am so tired of articles like these, passive aggressively aimed at making mothers feel guilty for choosing to give their baby formula, with absolutely no science used to back up any of the claims (while science does suggest breastfeeding can reduce sids and does help with immunity up to four months, the results are the same if the baby is 100% breastfed or formula and breastfed. Furthermore, because of the ethics of these studies, there are a ton of confounding variables that make it difficult for the scientists to draw conclusions. For example, these studies rarely compare siblings but instead study babies from vastly different socioeconomic backgrounds. In studies that did look at difference between formula and breast fed siblings that significance drastically decreased). Yes breastfeeding definitely has benefits studies do show this, but a depressed mother also is not healthy for the baby.

Articles like this, that passive aggressively weave guilt only serve to further upset/depress and demoralize already exhausted mothers. Let mothers make decisions with their pediatricians and with their family that is best for everybody. Enough already.

]]>
By: Neosha https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-135183 Thu, 06 Jun 2019 04:28:49 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-135183 In reply to Casey.

@Casey – Thank you for sharing with us. Please continue to take good care of yourself and your little guy!

]]>
By: Casey https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-135066 Mon, 03 Jun 2019 14:08:43 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-135066 Unfortunately it’s not so simple. I’ve just chosen to stop breastfeeding my almost 4th month old son, although this completely breaks my heart (and I want to try to restart someday), because he never slept well. We eventually had to do all his naps in the carrier, but this was unlivable. He wouldn’t sleep in the car; he screamed his head off. It turns out that the stress hormones (cortisol) in my milk were hurting his ability to calm down and sleep. I know many moms live on little sleep. Be aware that one night of bad sleep causes cortisol to be high the next day, because that’s what keeps you going. I am however a long time insomniac so my case is more extreme.

Anyway, I think it’s something of which women should be aware. Stress hormones pass into the milk. Reduce your stress. That means not too much exercise, not fasting or skipping meals or letting yourself go hungry at any point, getting enough sleep, not abusing lacto-fermented foods if you have sleep or blood sugar issues, not overstimulating your system with bad films/television or social media, not arguing with your husband, etc…

Do a cortisol saliva test if you want to make sure that this is not something affecting your baby.

]]>
By: T https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-134633 Tue, 21 May 2019 16:17:32 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-134633 In reply to Mimi.

THANK YOU for sharing! Though I like many of their articles, this one just rubs me the wrong way. I tried breastfeeding, and it just wasn’t working out. Instead of forcing it, which would have made things tougher and harder on both me and my baby, I pumped and supplemented with formula, then went to all formula. FORMULA. IS. NOT. BAD. There are so many amazing, organic formulas out there and women shouldn’t feel like they should keep forcing something just because “breast is best.” Breast is not always best. And while ignoring a doctor’s request and suggestion may work for some, it shouldn’t be something that is promoted.

]]>
By: Debbye @ The Baby Sleep Site https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-111511 Thu, 24 May 2018 05:24:14 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-111511 In reply to Em.

Hi @Em – Thank you for writing and for encouraging other parents! We are so happy to hear that you found this article helpful!

]]>
By: Em https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-111439 Tue, 22 May 2018 14:56:28 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-111439 Thank you so much for an article promoting breastfeeding with honesty and intelligence. You make some excellent points here.

To any mothers struggling with night-waking and worrying that formula might be ‘needed’, my paed told me that the night-waking breastfed babies do is normal and actually helps protect them from cot death. Waking every hour or two for breastfeeds is normal for very young babies, so something to be thankful for not to agonise over. Babies do wake up and yes it can be very tiring, but formula isn’t the answer. Soon you’ll look back and realise how fast those first baby months went. Enjoy every moment and congratulate yourself for all you do.

Please don’t ever think you’re ‘not good enough’ to breastfeed or that you’re not doing right by your baby. You most definitely ARE. Keep going!

Be proud : )

]]>
By: Emily DeJeu https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-35903 Wed, 23 May 2012 11:51:26 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-35903 @ Ayse — I can sympathize with this, too! I switched my youngest to formula right around 3 months, simply because she wasn’t gaining wait and didn’t seem to be satisfied when I nursed. It proved to be a good decision, but it was so hard. I still feel guilty sometimes 🙁

@ Leola — You know you’re exhausted when 5 straight hours of sleep is the dream!! Hope your little guy starts sleeping through the night soon (for your sake!) And remember — if you feel like you need to solicit some help in teaching him to sleep, don’t hesitate to contact us.

]]>
By: Leola https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-35881 Wed, 23 May 2012 07:04:53 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-35881 From birth my lil angel baby boy use to wake up e-v-e-r-y 2 hours to feed. Tried expressing with the thought behind it that maybe he doesn’t get enough although he was a chubby baby. That did not work. To say the least after 5 months I was so extremely tired! So tired to the extend I started to forget thing, thing like standing in the shower wondering if I still need to shower or did I just finish…and then showering again just to be sure, I kid you not. I decided that I was going to switch to formula. He still woke up every 2 hours. It gradually got less frequent and now he is 14 months and still wakes up every 4 hours! Noooo, hushing him back to sleep doesn’t help, water doesn’t help, and the letting him cry thing just doesn’t work for me I’m sorry. So I’m kinda at the point of just excepting it and hoping and praying for it to change. It’s not a case of he needs a bottle to sleep, he falls asleep just fine on his own in the day. And after his bottle, he just turns his cute lil but on me and that’s the sign for put me in my cot please. My mom said something interesting, that I was a thirsty child. I would even wake her up in the night for a drink of water. Later on she allowed me to take a class to bed. And today I take a bottle of water to bed. I will go crazy at night if I can’t have a drink of water when I want. That said, maybe it’s the case with my son, but I can hear his tummy rumble sometimes, and that after he had his dinner at 6, a bottle 7:30 and into bed. And still he wakes up 11:30 – 12. I’m dreaming of 5 full hours of sleep…mmmmmm….dreeeeaming….

]]>
By: Ayse https://www.babysleepsite.com/sleep-training/breastfeeding-supplement-switching-formula-help-baby-sleep/comment-page-3/#comment-35855 Wed, 23 May 2012 01:57:52 +0000 http://www.babysleepsite.com/?p=7866#comment-35855 @ Mimi, I totally understand…my first son was like that. Actually with my first the doctors convinced me that I didn’t have enough milk because he was crying a lot during the day, so at 5 weeks old I switched him to formula…he continued to wake up every 2 hrs to feed until he was 2.5 months, than he went right through the night. Switching to formula completely was probably the hardest thing I’ve ever had to do…I felt like I wasn’t providing for my baby the way God intended and I actually felt like a bad mom so I cried for days…3years later he is a very happy, healthy, and very smart little boy. When I had my daughter…3months ago, I was very lucky that she took to my breast with no problems and my milk supply was good. Her pediatrician told me to formula feeding her because she only gained 11 oz in a month…but I ignored his request

]]>